Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag was the last game in the franchise that I truly loved back in 2013. While Assassin’s Creed Shadows looked stunning, it never tempted me to truly explore its world. It wasn’t until I recently played Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynched that I remembered what made this game so special: it gives you the ultimate sense of freedom.
You set sail, chart your own course, dock at a random island, and almost always find something worthwhile waiting for you. Add satisfying naval combat, smooth parkour, and a beautiful Caribbean setting, and you’ve got an adventure that still feels surprisingly fresh more than a decade later. If you’re looking for games that capture that same feeling, you’ve come to the right place.
| Game | Looking for… |
| Assassin’s Creed Rogue | More Black Flag |
| Assassin’s Creed Odyssey | Freedom and island exploration |
| Sea of Thieves | The ultimate pirate fantasy |
| Ghost of Yōtei | A world worth getting lost in |
| Sid Meier’s Pirates! | A classic pirate adventure |
| Skull and Bones | More naval combat |
| Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii | A humorous pirate adventure |
| Red Dead Redemption 2 | A living open world |
| The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom | Curiosity-driven exploration |
| Outer Wilds | Discovering the unknown |
| Subnautica | Ocean exploration |
| Assassin’s Creed Freedom Cry | More adventures in the Caribbean |
| LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean | Family-friendly pirate fun |
| Windward | Relaxing sailing |
| Salt 2 | Survival and exploration |
Assassin’s Creed Rogue

Play this if: you finished Black Flag and immediately wanted more Black Flag.
If you’ve finished Black Flag but still aren’t ready to stop boarding enemy ships, then Assassin’s Creed Rogue is the most obvious next step. It builds on almost everything that made Black Flag so enjoyable (although that doesn’t necessarily mean it does everything better). Once again, you’ll explore an open world by sea, engage in naval battles, and continue upgrading your ship as you drift further and further away from the beaten path.
That said, Rogue never feels like a simple copy. The sunny Caribbean is replaced by the icy waters of the North Atlantic, giving the game a very different atmosphere. This time, you step into the shoes of Shay Cormac, an Assassin who defects to the Templars, offering a fresh perspective on the conflict you’ve come to know throughout the series.
Black Flag is still the superior game without question, but if you’re looking for the same blend of naval combat, exploration, and freedom, nothing comes closer than Assassin’s Creed Rogue.
Assassin’s Creed Odyssey

Play this if: your favourite part of Black Flag was exploring islands and the freedom to go wherever you wanted.
Don’t worry, I’m not going to recommend every Assassin’s Creed game. Odyssey definitely deserves a spot on this list, though. The Aegean Sea is packed with islands that constantly tempt you to stray from your planned route. Before you know it, you’re exploring another cave, clearing out a fort, or searching for hidden treasure, even though you originally intended to make some progress on the main story.
Just like in Black Flag, your ship plays an important role, although the focus is less on naval combat this time around. You’ll still encounter enemy vessels, upgrade your ship, and spend plenty of time sailing, but Odyssey is ultimately more about its enormous open world and the freedom to create your own adventure.
So don’t expect a second Black Flag. Odyssey leans less into the pirate fantasy and more into ancient Greek mythology and warfare. But if it was the thrill of exploration that made you fall in love with Black Flag, then Assassin’s Creed Odyssey might just be its best modern successor.
Sea of Thieves

Play this if: your favourite part of Black Flag was living the life of a pirate.
No game makes you feel like a pirate quite the way Sea of Thieves does. You raise the sails alongside your crew, hunt for buried treasure, engage in thrilling naval battles, and regularly stumble into unexpected situations along the way. Almost every adventure unfolds naturally, meaning no two play sessions ever feel quite the same.
Where Black Flag tells a memorable story, Sea of Thieves lets you create your own. That does mean you shouldn’t expect a lengthy single-player campaign or unforgettable characters like Edward Kenway. Instead, the focus is entirely on exploring the seas and setting off on adventures with your crew.
If you’re mainly chasing the pirate fantasy that Black Flag captured so well, Sea of Thieves is an excellent choice. Just keep in mind that it’s a very different experience. Black Flag tells a story; in Sea of Thieves, you’re the one writing it.
Ghost of Yōtei

Play this if: you completely lost yourself in the world of Black Flag.
At first glance, Ghost of Yōtei has very little in common with Black Flag. You trade the Caribbean Sea for the rugged northern regions of Japan, and the life of a pirate for that of a ronin. Yet while playing, I found myself experiencing that same feeling over and over again. The world constantly encourages you to leave the beaten path, and before long you’re exploring another cave, discovering a hidden shrine, or meeting an intriguing new character.
Like Black Flag, Ghost of Yōtei isn’t just about completing missions. It’s the journey between those missions that makes the game so special. You spot something interesting on the horizon, decide to take a quick detour, and an hour later you’re still nowhere near the objective you originally set out to reach. That constant sense of freedom and curiosity reminded me of Black Flag time and time again.
Of course, don’t expect naval battles or pirate adventures. But if what you loved most was exploring an open world that constantly rewards your curiosity, then Ghost of Yōtei is, in my opinion, one of the very best modern alternatives.
I gave Ghost of Yōtei a 9/10 in my review, which you can read here.
Sid Meier’s Pirates!

Play this if: you’re looking for the ultimate pirate fantasy.
Don’t let its age put you off. Sid Meier’s Pirates! was originally released in 1987 before receiving a remake in 2004, yet many fans still consider it one of the greatest pirate games ever made. For good reason, too. You’re given complete freedom to explore the Caribbean, board enemy ships, trade goods, hunt for treasure, and build your reputation as a feared pirate.
Unlike Black Flag, the story takes a back seat. Much like Sea of Thieves, Sid Meier’s Pirates! is all about creating your own adventure. You decide which ships to attack, which missions to take on, and how your name will be remembered. That freedom is exactly what makes the game so addictive, even all these years later.
Of course, don’t expect modern visuals or cinematic storytelling. But if the pirate life itself was your favorite part of Black Flag, then Sid Meier’s Pirates! is a classic you really shouldn’t skip.
Skull and Bones

Play this if: your favorite part of Black Flag was its naval combat.
When Skull and Bones was first announced, many players hoped it would become the spiritual successor to Black Flag. That never really happened. Even so, it absolutely deserves a place on this list. If you spent hours boarding ships, upgrading the Jackdaw, and taking part in epic naval battles, Skull and Bones still has plenty to offer.
The game focuses almost entirely on life at sea. You’ll gather resources, build increasingly powerful ships, and battle enemy fleets across the open ocean. Its naval combat is more in-depth and tactical than Black Flag’s, making ship upgrades and weapon choices an even bigger part of the experience.
Just don’t expect the same sense of adventure. While Black Flag excelled at rewarding exploration, telling a memorable story, and seamlessly letting you switch between life on land and at sea, Skull and Bones remains much more focused on its core gameplay loop. If you’re mainly looking for deeper naval combat, you’ll have a great time. If you’re hoping for a second Black Flag, you’ll probably be disappointed.
Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii

Play this if: you’re in the mood for a lighter pirate adventure.
Not every game on this list tries to recreate Black Flag, and Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii is probably the best example of that. As you’d expect from the Like a Dragon series, it’s much crazier and more humorous than your typical pirate adventure. Even so, you’ll still spend plenty of time exploring the seas, upgrading your ship, and battling rival crews.
The game makes no attempt to be historically accurate, instead fully embracing its over-the-top style. Expect bizarre characters, ridiculous missions, and plenty of laugh-out-loud moments. It makes Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii a completely different experience from Black Flag, but a refreshing one nonetheless.
If you’re looking for a serious successor to Black Flag, then Assassin’s Creed Rogue or Assassin’s Creed Odyssey are much better choices. But if you’re simply after a fun pirate adventure that doesn’t take itself too seriously, then Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii is an easy recommendation.
Red Dead Redemption 2

Play this if: you loved getting completely lost in the world of Black Flag.
On paper, Black Flag and Red Dead Redemption 2 have very little in common. One is about pirates, the other about outlaws in the Wild West. Yet while playing Red Dead Redemption 2, I often experienced the exact same feeling. You’re on your way to a mission, spot something interesting in the distance, decide to take a quick detour, and before you know it, an hour has passed and you’ve completely forgotten where you were originally headed.
That’s largely because both games constantly reward your curiosity. Whether you wander into an abandoned cabin, follow an unfamiliar trail, or stumble across a random encounter, there’s almost always something worth discovering. Just like Black Flag, the world never feels like a collection of map icons. Instead, it feels like a place you’ll happily lose yourself in.
Just don’t expect a pirate adventure filled with naval battles and parkour. Red Dead Redemption 2 earned its place on this list because it captures that same sense of freedom and discovery. If that’s what made you fall in love with Black Flag, you’re going to feel right at home here.
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom

Play this if: you love being constantly rewarded for your curiosity.
One of Black Flag’s greatest strengths is that you’ll almost always find something worthwhile when you decide to leave the beaten path. The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom does exactly the same. Spot a strange rock formation, a floating island, or a mysterious cave? Chances are there’s something genuinely interesting waiting for you there. As a result, exploration never feels like wasted time.
While Black Flag gives you the freedom to explore the seas, Tears of the Kingdom offers that same freedom across land and sky. You’ll climb mountains, glide through the air, and even build your own vehicles to reach places that initially seem impossible to access. The world constantly encourages you to experiment and forge your own path.
Of course, don’t expect a historical setting or naval combat. But if your favorite moments in Black Flag came from simply wondering what was waiting beyond the next horizon, then The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom captures that feeling better than almost any other game.
Outer Wilds

Play this if: your favorite part of Black Flag was discovering the unknown.
No, Outer Wilds isn’t a pirate game. Even so, I kept thinking about it while putting this list together. Much like Black Flag, it’s a game driven entirely by curiosity. You’re given very little direction, encouraging you to venture out and uncover its mysteries on your own. That freedom is exactly what makes every new discovery feel so rewarding.
Instead of sailing across the Caribbean, you’ll travel through a compact solar system filled with fascinating planets, each hiding its own secrets and puzzles. The less you know about Outer Wilds before you start, the better. Almost everything you uncover feels like a reward for your own curiosity rather than another objective on a checklist.
So don’t expect sword fights, ship cannons, or a historical setting. Outer Wilds is on this list because it captures Black Flag at its very best: that irresistible urge to keep exploring simply because you want to know what’s waiting beyond the next horizon.
Subnautica

Play this if: you loved getting completely lost while exploring the world of Black Flag.
Subnautica may be the most unusual recommendation on this list, but it’s also one of the strongest. Instead of sailing across the Caribbean, you’ll explore an alien ocean filled with colorful coral reefs, mysterious caves, and gigantic sea creatures. Much like Black Flag, it’s not just about reaching your destination, but everything you discover along the way.
The deeper you dive, the more new biomes, resources, and secrets you’ll uncover. That feeling of always daring to venture just a little bit further regularly reminded me of those moments in Black Flag when you decided to leave your planned route behind to see what was waiting beyond an unfamiliar island.
Just don’t expect pirates, sword fights, or ship cannons. Subnautica earned its place on this list because it sparks that same sense of curiosity. If your favorite moments in Black Flag came from sailing toward the horizon simply to see what was out there, chances are Subnautica will hook you just as much.
Assassin’s Creed Freedom Cry

Play this if: you weren’t ready to leave the Caribbean after finishing Black Flag.
Alright, alright… just one more Assassin’s Creed game. Assassin’s Creed Freedom Cry started life as an expansion for Black Flag, but it feels much more like a standalone adventure. This time, you step into the shoes of Adéwalé, Edward Kenway’s former quartermaster. While the game is considerably shorter, you’ll immediately recognize the familiar mix of naval combat, exploration, and stealth.
What sets Freedom Cry apart is its story. Adéwalé fights to free enslaved people, giving the game a more serious and emotional tone than Black Flag. It gives the adventure its own identity without abandoning the gameplay that made Black Flag so memorable.
Did you skip Freedom Cry because you thought it was “just DLC”? Then this is the perfect time to correct that mistake. Don’t expect a massive open world, but do expect an adventure that every Black Flag fan should experience.
LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean

Play this if: you’re in the mood for a lighthearted pirate adventure.
LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean might not be the most obvious choice, but don’t overlook it. The humor, iconic locations, and, of course, the memorable characters from the movies quickly pull you back into the pirate fantasy. On top of that, it’s surprisingly well-designed whether you’re playing solo or with someone else in local co-op.
Naturally, the gameplay is much simpler than Black Flag’s. Don’t expect to upgrade your ship or engage in large-scale naval battles. Instead, the game focuses on exploration, puzzles, and uncovering hidden secrets, exactly what you’d expect from a great LEGO title.
If you’re looking for a serious successor to Black Flag, there are stronger options on this list. But if you’re after a relaxed pirate adventure packed with charm and humor, or simply want something the whole family can enjoy, LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean is still surprisingly entertaining.
Windward

Play this if: your favorite part of Black Flag was simply sailing wherever you wanted.
Windward proves you don’t need a massive budget to create an enjoyable pirate game. You start with a modest ship and gradually work your way up by trading goods, completing missions, and taking down enemy vessels. Meanwhile, the entire world is yours to explore, allowing you to decide exactly where your next voyage will take you.
Unlike Black Flag, Windward places very little emphasis on storytelling. Instead, it focuses almost entirely on exploring the world, upgrading your ship, and taking on increasingly challenging naval battles. That’s exactly what makes it such a relaxing game to play at your own pace.
Windward may lack the cinematic presentation and memorable characters of Black Flag, but it captures the simple joy of setting sail remarkably well. If you’re looking for a laid-back pirate experience where you chart your own course, this indie title is well worth checking out.
Salt 2

Play this if: you wanted to create your own adventure.
Where Black Flag tells a memorable pirate story, Salt 2 gives you complete freedom to forge your own path. You’ll explore a vast ocean filled with islands, hunt for treasure, gather resources, and slowly build your own adventure. The game offers very little direction, making curiosity your greatest motivation from the very beginning.
The survival mechanics ensure that every discovery genuinely matters. Better equipment, stronger weapons, or a safe island where you can catch your breath all have a meaningful impact on your journey. As a result, Salt 2 focuses less on spectacular action and more on the satisfaction of exploring and surviving.
So don’t expect a gripping narrative like the one found in Black Flag. Salt 2 is designed for players who love sailing toward the horizon without a plan and deciding for themselves what kind of adventure they’ll have. If that was your favorite part of Black Flag, then Salt 2 is the perfect way to wrap up this list.
Still looking for something to play? Check out Find Your Next Game for more games similar to your favorites.






