For the Stories Worth Playing

Gears of War: E-Day Campaign Review – Relentless Action, Missed Potential

In the words of the legendary Marcus Fenix: “Rest in pieces.” That’s apparently what I subconsciously told the Gears of War franchise after finishing the second game back in 2008. Strange, considering I was obsessed with the first two games. Why I never played the third remains a mystery to me. Maybe teenage Dustin was simply broke. We’ll never know.

What I do know, however, is that Gears of War: E-Day felt like stepping into a time machine. Hearing Marcus’s deep, commanding voice, Locust barking words like “Groundwalker” at me, and the familiar roar of the spinning chainsaw attached to my rifle; thanks to E-Day, I was 18 years old again.

But was this a glorious return to form, or does E-Day rely too heavily on nostalgia? That’s what I hope to answer in this spoiler-free review. Fair warning, though: there will be spoilers for earlier games in the franchise.

This review focuses exclusively on the single-player campaign. Other game modes are not included in this review.

Back to the beginning

While the original Gears of War games take place roughly 14 years into the war against the Locust, The Coalition’s E-Day takes us back to… well, E-Day. Emergence Day marks the moment the Locust emerge from beneath the surface, seemingly with only one goal in mind: wiping out humanity.

Gears of War: E-Day takes place six weeks after the end of the Pendulum Wars, a conflict that lasted nearly 80 years. Peace has finally arrived, but humanity doesn’t get much time to enjoy it.

See Also  Do You Need to Play Gears of War Before E-Day?

Our old friends Marcus and Dom reunite during a ceremony honoring fallen soldiers, including Dom’s older brother Carlos, who was also Marcus’s best friend. The two head out for a drink, where Dom reveals his plans to leave the military behind and settle down with his wife Maria and their children. This is where the power of a prequel immediately becomes apparent. Knowing what eventually happens to Dom’s family makes his plans all the more heartbreaking.

Marcus, on the other hand, has no intention of leaving the military. Being a soldier is all he knows, and the thought of an ordinary civilian life doesn’t particularly appeal to him. Well, let’s just say he gets his wish. And then some.

The outbreak and ensuing panic are brilliantly portrayed

Tremors shake the bar, and an emergency broadcast reports similar incidents across the city. You take control of Marcus for the first time, heading out into the streets alongside Dom, Lucas, and Mags (two other people who happened to be at the bar) as panic begins to spread. It quickly becomes clear that these aren’t ordinary earthquakes. Sirens wail in the distance, alarms go off, and ominous screams echo through the streets.

And before I can even fully appreciate how gorgeous the tree-lined streets look, illuminated by neon signs and car headlights, the road suddenly splits open right in front of me. A red glow rises from the depths, as if a literal gateway to hell has opened beneath our feet. Countless bloodthirsty creatures pour out, tearing apart everything and everyone in their path.

And that impressive first impression is no exception. E-Day looks fantastic throughout the entire campaign. The detailed environments, atmospheric lighting, and sheer devastation left in the Locust’s wake never fail to impress. Everywhere you look, there’s rubble, smoke, and burning buildings. It really feels like you’re witnessing the collapse of an entire civilization.

The action still feels fantastic, which is a good thing, because there’s plenty of it

The first Locust emerging from the ground are no match for you and your teammates, who will become known as Bravo Squad the following day. But Gears of War: E-Day quickly ramps things up. So-called Emergence Holes appear all over the city, and you’ll encounter increasingly dangerous Locust as the campaign progresses.

Just when you think you’ve got the Locust figured out, another new variant comes along, often sporting a grotesque and downright creepy design. Think sniping Locust, enormous minigun-wielding brutes, or oversized, acid-spitting toads. And sometimes, all of them at once.

Fortunately, the game gives you more than enough tools to deal with these threats. The classic snap-to-cover mechanic still feels just as satisfying as it did back in the day. There’s something oddly exhilarating about watching these massive, heavily armored soldiers slam themselves into cover, helped in no small part by the excellent sound design.

“Which piece of cover will you move to when your current position becomes compromised? Which Locust poses the biggest threat right now? Constantly assessing the situation and staying on the move is essential…”


Don’t expect your carefully chosen cover to keep you safe forever, though. Enemies are smart enough to flank you, charge straight at you, or simply blast your cover to pieces. This means you constantly need to stay alert and keep an eye on the entire battlefield. Which piece of cover will you move to when your current position becomes compromised? Which Locust poses the biggest threat right now? Constantly assessing the situation and staying on the move is essential, especially on Hardcore difficulty and above, where you can afford far fewer downs than on the more forgiving settings.

Speaking of difficulty, E-Day lets you customize it to your liking. For example, you can make Normal a little more challenging by reducing the number of downs you’re allowed and limiting the ammunition available. Or you can keep everything on Hardcore while giving yourself a few extra chances to go down. It’s a welcome feature that lets you fine-tune the experience to match your preferences.

A wide arsenal of weapons, with mods to make them your own

Gears of War: E-Day doesn’t just make defensive tactics satisfying; dishing out damage to those damn “grubs” feels just as good. And the more you watch them tear apart “our” world and its inhabitants, the more motivated you become to wipe them off the face of the earth.

With 16 weapons to choose from, alongside various grenades and traps, there’s plenty of variety. From the shotgun-like Gnasher and sniper rifle-like Longshot to heavy Locust weaponry such as the Troika and the gruesome Gorehook, which can practically turn an enemy inside out. Lovely!

Every weapon feels great to use, but each comes with its own strengths and weaknesses. Although I’d settled on my go-to combination of the Ripper and Longshot about halfway through the campaign, I would’ve loved to carry a Gnasher as well. Some Locust charge straight at you, making the Gnasher particularly useful, while enemy snipers are best dealt with by giving them a taste of their own medicine. But hey… you can’t have it all.

Fortunately, you can tweak your weapons to suit your preferences through mods. Eventually, you can equip each weapon with three mods, plus an additional bonus triggered by a perfect reload. That classic little minigame where you have to time your reload just right is still as engaging as ever, by the way. Mods can increase your magazine capacity, speed up your reloads, or even make the chainsaw on your Lancer rev up faster.

Whichever trigger you end up pulling, taking down a Locust never gets old. The gore makes every kill feel that much more rewarding, and the sound of a Locust’s head exploding is just chef’s kiss.

I’m not a psychopath, I swear… at least, not as far as I know.

Collect mods by exploring and completing secondary objectives

If you want to pimp your guns, you can find hard cases scattered throughout the game world or earn them by completing secondary objectives. Parts of E-Day feature semi-open areas, allowing you to either make a beeline for your main objective or take your time exploring. Venture off the beaten path, and you might discover additional hard cases or stumble upon secondary objectives.

These secondary objectives often involve assisting fellow COG squads. One of the cooler ones, for example, had me helping a sniper who’d lost his spotter. He wanted revenge, and who were we to deny the poor guy that? These objectives add even more combat to the experience and are especially worthwhile early on, when you’re still building up your collection of mods.

Later in the game, however, I found myself increasingly less interested in pursuing these objectives. The main campaign already throws more than enough combat at you, and there are so many mods that hunting them all down eventually stops feeling worthwhile, especially once you’re happy with your loadout.

From a storytelling perspective, I didn’t feel much incentive to stray from my main objective either. Most secondary objectives revolve around soldiers who’ve gotten themselves into trouble and need help fending off waves of Locust. They’re a nice bonus for anyone craving even more combat, but personally, I didn’t feel they added much to the overall experience.

“There’s something incredibly satisfying about watching your carefully prepared defenses hold up as Locust keep pouring in from every direction.”


And if the main and secondary objectives somehow still aren’t enough to satisfy your appetite for action, you can even stumble upon encounters outside of those. At one point, I was walking through the streets when I came across a group of soldiers preparing an ambush. They asked for my help, so I placed some mine traps and machine gun sentries in strategically advantageous positions. Before long, the Locust showed up. Together, we tore them to shreds.

And it’s precisely these moments, when you’re building a defensive line alongside fellow soldiers, that rank among my favorite parts of E-Day. Even during the main campaign, you’ll regularly get the opportunity to prepare your defenses before waves of Locust come charging at you. You lay traps, set up sentries, and try to anticipate where the enemy will strike from. And then all hell breaks loose. There’s something incredibly satisfying about watching your carefully prepared defenses hold up as Locust keep pouring in from every direction.

This is something Gears of War: E-Day does exceptionally well. From beginning to end, there’s a genuine sense of “us against them,” reinforced by rousing speeches from commanding officers, conversations between soldiers, and the sheer magnitude of what’s at stake.

Strong camaraderie, but a story that doesn’t live up to its potential

In my memory, Gears of War was always much more than just a shooter. I still remember how impressed I was by Epic Games’ storytelling back in the day. Gears of War 2 features one particular moment between Dom and his wife Maria that has stuck with me to this day. It was so shocking and heartbreaking that I can still picture the scene vividly.

But have I built up the storytelling in my head to be better than it actually was? Or does E-Day simply take a step back in that department? Either way, I honestly expected more.

In this prequel, you largely go from one firefight to the next. Through dialogue and the occasional cutscene, you get to know newcomers Lucas and Mags a little better, while also watching the bond between Marcus and Dom grow stronger. But in my opinion, the game doesn’t make nearly enough of these moments.

Whenever E-Day takes its foot off the gas, you can see just how much potential these characters have. At one point, for example, Mags reminds Marcus that Dom and Lucas look up to him and need him to be a leader. Conversations like these remind me why I was so impressed by Gears of War‘s storytelling all those years ago.

“Whenever E-Day takes its foot off the gas, you can see just how much potential these characters have.”


The bond between the four does grow, but the game rarely takes the time to truly explore it. Before you know it, you’re thrown into yet another firefight. A few more quiet moments would have done the story a world of good.

Individually, the characters also feel somewhat underdeveloped. For most of the campaign, Marcus remains the gruff, mission-focused soldier we know and love, armed with an endless supply of cheesy one-liners that he somehow still manages to pull off. Dom undergoes the most noticeable development, largely because of his family circumstances.

Mags and Lucas both had the potential to become genuinely interesting characters. It’s clear that Mags carries quite a bit of emotional baggage. She’s good at reading her teammates and knows when to speak up and when to keep quiet. Lucas, meanwhile, provides some occasional comic relief with his random facts and seems a little more overwhelmed by everything happening around him than the other three. We do get to see more of him later in the campaign, but these moments feel too isolated to leave a lasting impression.

Ultimately, it’s the action, spectacle, and strong sense of camaraderie that make E-Day an enjoyable experience. That combination kept me entertained from beginning to end. But the fact that the storytelling falls short makes it all the more frustrating, especially when the game’s best moments show just how much more it could have been.

Some Loose Scraps

  • Sometimes, while playing as Marcus, I’d keep my squad waiting while I searched for ammo or hard cases. What always cracked me up was Marcus himself suddenly shouting things like “HEY! Get a move on!” even though he was the one holding everyone up.
  • You’re supposed to close Emergence Holes by throwing grenades into them, or the Locust just keep coming. I’ve wasted far too many grenades by missing my throws. The game could really do a better job of showing you where to aim. Or maybe I’m just terrible at throwing grenades…
  • “Look ma, no face,” “Come to papa,” “Lights out, fuckface.” Yep, you can always count on our boy Marcus to deliver a cheesy one-liner.
  • Sometimes I’d get a bit frustrated after being killed. But then I’d hear a Locust say “Dead Ooman,” and honestly, how could I stay mad?
  • To recreate the chainsaw sound of the original Lancer from the first Gears of War, developer The Coalition tracked down the exact same model of chainsaw used back in 2006. So if, like me, you thought that sound was awfully familiar, there’s a good reason for that.

Conclusion

Gears of War: E-Day is a fantastic action game, with the emphasis firmly on action. Blood practically splatters off the screen during its countless spectacular action sequences, which never fail to impress.

It’s quite an achievement that the action remains so entertaining throughout the entire campaign. The classic snap-to-cover and perfect-reload mechanics still feel as satisfying as ever, while delivering a healthy dose of nostalgia. Slicing Locust apart with a chainsaw or blasting them to pieces never gets old, thanks in no small part to the diverse arsenal of weapons that all feel fantastic to use.

But while the action lived up to my high expectations, the story didn’t. Gears of War: E-Day plays it safe with its storytelling. Every now and then, it shows glimpses of its potential when it steps away from the action and gives its characters room to breathe. Unfortunately, these moments are too few and far between, and rarely explored deeply enough to leave the kind of lasting impression that earlier games in the franchise left on me.

Reviewed on: PC (Xbox Game Pass)
Score: 8/10

Never miss a game worth playing

Get new reviews, game recommendations and the occasional questionable opinion straight to your inbox.

Share
Share

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts