For the Stories Worth Playing

Silver Pines Review: Survival Horror Worth Exploring

*A review code was provided for this game.

How scary can a 2.5D side-scroller really be? That was my first thought when I started Wych Elm Games’ survival horror game Silver Pines. And yes, I personally do find 3D horror scarier. But Silver Pines achieves something at least as impressive: keeping you uneasy from beginning to end. What more could you ask for?

This review contains no spoilers.

Searching for Eddie Velvet

Silver Pines Review - Walker speaking with his client over the phone, who makes it clear that finding Eddie will make his troubles melt away.

Silver Pines follows private investigator Red Walker as he searches for Eddie Velvet in a small town largely evacuated ahead of an approaching storm. The missing musician has been linked to the disappearance of a young woman. How Walker ended up in Silver Pines in the first place, however, is something he can’t remember.

The people who stayed behind aren’t exactly forthcoming, either. Your mysterious client calls to stress how important it is that you find Eddie, while many of the other characters you encounter speak so cryptically that you leave most conversations wondering: what on earth did I just listen to?

Silver Pines keeps its cards close to its chest, leaving plenty open to interpretation and keeping you in the dark, both literally and figuratively. Don’t expect a story that spells everything out or constantly delivers major revelations.

How much that approach draws you in will likely depend on whether you prefer clear answers or enjoy piecing things together and developing your own theories. Personally, I prefer my storytelling a little more direct.

There’s a clear comparison to Silent Hill 2 here. And the similarities extend well beyond the storytelling.

An interconnected maze with puzzles that never frustrate

Silver Pines Review - An example of an in-game puzzle, showing a bunch of words and letters against a red lit background.

Silver Pines brings a Metroidvania structure to its survival horror. The town is one sprawling maze of interconnected paths and areas, many of which remain inaccessible until you find the right tool. Expect plenty of backtracking as new discoveries give you reasons to revisit familiar places.

Beyond the obvious horror and oppressive atmosphere, puzzles are another thing it shares with Silent Hill. You regularly encounter padlocked doors, locked safes, and better weapons tucked away behind locks. Progress toward your main objective also frequently depends on finding specific key items.

See Also  Silent Hill 2 Remake: How Mannequins and Toluca Prison Pushed Me to the Limit

For me, the puzzles strike exactly the right balance. They’re never so difficult that they become frustrating (or worse, make you feel stupid), but they aren’t so straightforward that you can solve them without thinking, either. They demand just enough to leave you thinking: pretty pleased with myself for figuring that one out.

Knowing that your solution will earn you a useful addition to your arsenal, or simply bring you one step closer to your goal, makes solving them consistently satisfying.

The level design is fantastic, and every new room is a pleasure to discover

Silver Pines Review - Walker standing in front of a church building. The environment is dark and rainy.

Silver Pines keeps delivering little bursts of excitement. Every time I opened a previously blocked path, I looked forward to discovering what waited on the other side. Whether it was a room full of grotesque enemies, a little green herb to restore my health (now, where have we seen that before?), or a document shedding a little more light on the Eddie Velvet case, exploring always felt rewarding.

“Every time I opened a previously blocked path, I looked forward to discovering what waited on the other side.”


And even if I found absolutely nothing, I would still have been happy to discover another corner of its gorgeous world. Silver Pines is a feast for the eyes. From its drab streets, town hall, and suspiciously quiet motel to the blood-red environments that signal an approaching boss fight, everything looks beautiful and deeply ominous. I believed this town had been abandoned. More importantly, I felt it. As though someone had taken the whole place and wrung every last drop of goodness out of it.

There’s also an impressive sense of depth to its 2.5D environments. Large buildings loom in the background, some you’ve already visited and others still on your list of places to explore.

Silver Pines Review - A view of the map.

Navigation is pretty straightforward thanks to a clear map that marks areas you can’t access yet. You also have a camera, which lets you photograph points of interest and pin the pictures to the map. Find a puzzle you don’t yet know how to solve? Take a photo, and you’ll have a handy reminder when you’re ready to return.

The atmosphere, puzzles, and level design are Silver Pines’ greatest strengths. They made my roughly 15-hour playthrough so enjoyable that I would happily have spent twice as long there. They also helped me forgive the game’s biggest weakness: combat.

Which resources are you willing to sacrifice?

Silver Pines Review - The inventory screen.

You encounter all kinds of monstrosities throughout your adventure. Sometimes you can sneak past them, run away, or stand your ground and fight. I played on the recommended “Survival Horror” difficulty, where ammunition and healing supplies are limited. That means carefully weighing your options before deciding how to proceed.

In some similar games, escaping is as simple as reaching the next room. That won’t always save you here. Enemies can follow you through doors or into the next area as the screen scrolls along. They also have a habit of lurking exactly where your next important item happens to be. Sometimes, fighting is your only real option.

See Also  Alan Wake 2 Doesn’t Need Hostiles to Be Terrifying

You can put them down with your precious ammunition or use a melee weapon, depending on what you’ve brought along. Walker’s inventory space is limited, so you can’t carry everything you’d like.

Shooting monsters from a distance is naturally the safer option, but you might regret those spent bullets when you’re running dry during a boss fight. Melee combat, meanwhile, leaves you more exposed to damage. Then you need to heal, and what if you run out of healing supplies later? You’re constantly assessing what you have left and what you’re willing to sacrifice. So far, so good.

Red Walker is no James Bond

Silver Pines Review - Walker readying his knife, while one monster is walking toward him and another one is getting up.

Many Metroidvanias revolve around fast-paced combat and give you an agile protagonist to match. Don’t expect that from Silver Pines. Walker is no James Bond. This private investigator knows his way around a gun, but that’s about where his combat credentials end.

Up close, your options largely come down to dodging and swinging your weapon. Both consume stamina, and your choice of melee weapon makes a substantial difference to how quickly you tire yourself out. Especially early on, your stamina bar empties quickly, leaving you vulnerable. Many monsters are fairly slow, but they certainly hit hard.

Not every blow staggers an enemy, either. That depends on how much you charge your swing and the condition of your weapon. Once a monster catches you, things can quickly spiral out of your control, especially when several enemies are after you at once.

“These encounters often felt more like ‘resources versus monster’ than ‘Walker versus monster.”


Being well prepared means having healing supplies and spare ammunition on hand, but Walker is in no hurry to use either. Healing and reloading take time, and monsters don’t always give you the breathing room to get back into fighting shape. That can be frustrating, particularly during boss fights.

Enemy movesets aren’t especially varied. Most regular monsters rely on a single attack, while the bosses I fought generally had three. After a few deaths, their patterns became fairly easy to read. Yet these encounters often felt more like “resources versus monster” than “Walker versus monster.” Most of the bosses I faced had far too much health. At one point, I emptied two full shotgun magazines (8 bullets) into a creature’s face, and it still wouldn’t go down.

After boss fights, I was always left feeling that my ammunition and weapons had won the battle, rather than me. Mostly, I was just glad the fight was over so I could return to what the game does best: exploration. And part of what makes that so enjoyable is something I haven’t even given its due yet.

The soundtrack and sound design take the experience to another level

Silver Pines Review - Walker standing in a red lit environemnt, with a voice whispering 'Red Light'.

My parents were staying with us and getting ready for bed when I decided to play a little Silver Pines. After hearing its melancholy, ominous background music, my father poked his head around the door and asked, “What’s this dark, mysterious game you’re playing?” Mission accomplished, then.

Because dark and mysterious it certainly is. As if Silver Pines’ washed-out colors and unsettling visuals weren’t enough, the soundtrack adds another layer of unease. As you walk its rain-soaked streets, the music keeps you anticipating something terrible. Something is coming, and any moment now, you’re going to find out what.

“Something is coming, and any moment now, you’re going to find out what.”


The enemies’ groans and cries make things even creepier. Their wailing suggests that the creatures themselves are suffering, almost making you feel as though putting them out of their misery would be a kindness. Other times they growl, and suddenly it’s clear that they’re the hunters, not you.

I also noticed that the same enemy types sometimes made different sounds. At one point, I entered a building and heard a very threatening noise I didn’t recognize. The hairs on the back of my neck stood up, and I braced myself for the worst. It turned out to be a monster I’d encountered before, but its unfamiliar sound still managed to put me on edge. It’s a clever way to keep a relatively limited variety of enemies unsettling.

Some Loose Scraps

Silver Pines Review - Walker rolling a trolley.
  • Is there a more satisfying discovery in survival horror than an inventory upgrade? I don’t think so.
  • You can find coffee machines that permanently increase your stamina. A considerably better deal than the short-lived boost coffee gives you in real life.
  • Optional bosses in games with limited resources always leave me torn. Won’t I spend just as many precious supplies as I stand to gain? I’ll never know, because I’d rather keep mine.
  • Saving requires using a payphone. First, you insert a coin, then dial your client’s number. Only after the call is your progress saved. I expected this routine to become tedious, but it actually helped keep me immersed in the world.
  • Nearby TVs regularly switch on to broadcast cryptic shows that shed some light on your investigation, much like Alan Wake.
  • The developers filmed some monster movements backward, then reversed the animation frames to create a subtly unnatural effect. Walker alone required over 1,800 hand-drawn frames.
  • Silver Pines took four years to develop, with a core team of just five people.

Conclusion

Silver Pines Review - Rating screen: 8,5/10.

What Silver Pines does well, it does brilliantly. Exploration takes center stage and remains engaging and rewarding right up to the end. Whether you find new weapons and ammunition, Mementos that grant useful bonuses, or essential healing supplies, searching a room always feels worth your time.

A sense of dread and hopelessness hangs over everything, reinforced by the fantastic art direction and excellent sound design.

Combat is clunky and sometimes frustrating, often feeling like an interruption you have to endure before you can get back to exploring. The story unfolds slowly and offers its revelations sparingly, leaving much open to interpretation.

Ultimately, the outstanding level design and haunting atmosphere become the real stars of the show. And they’re more than enough to make Silver Pines a must-play for survival horror fans.

Reviewed on: Playstation 5
Score: 8.5/10

Never miss a game worth playing

Get new reviews, game recommendations and the occasional questionable opinion straight to your inbox.

Share
Share

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts